Q1. Could Mark Nicholson from auditor BDO please comment on his approach to the US fraud situation. Were the auditors involved in helping detect the fraud and what changes to our auditing processes have we made? If we had a Big Four auditor, could the CFO comment on whether the fraud might have potentially been detected earlier or was this an issue which even the world's best auditor would have missed?
Answer: The auditor and CFO Amanda Cribb both had a good crack at explaining the fraud. Amanda said it was discovered by the company, not the auditor, and we'll never know if a Big Four audit firm would have spotted it earlier. Watch video of exchange via Twitter.
Q2. The Bailador AGM a few weeks ago was heavy going for the directors with their stock trading at a 50% discount to NTA. As our original sponsor, why isn't Bailador featuring more prominently in today's capital raising announcement and once the dust has settled on the raise, what percentage of the business will Bailador own? The nominee director for Bailador, Helen Foley, quit the board in June this year. Does this mean they are going, going, gone from our business?
Answer: The embattled chair Linda Jenkinson, whose options grant was defeated today, said Bailador remained on the register and could well participate in the rights issue. Watch video of exchange via Twitter.
Q3. Today's capital raising announcement means will we have to incur the expense of holding an EGM on December 14, in part to approve the proposed placement to entities associated with director Ronald Heinz? Why didn't we get this raising deal completed in time for the approvals to be provided at today's AGM and why is Ronald Heinz the only director stepping up above and beyond his pro-rata entitlement?"
Answer: CFO Amanda Cribb provided the following written response via Zoom: Thank you, Mr Mayne. I'll take your three questions in turn. First, the EGM. The proposed placement to Oquirrh Ventures is to an entity associated with a director, Ron Heinz. Under ASX Listing Rule 10.11, an issue of shares to a related party requires shareholder approval, whatever its size. The Board can't avoid that requirement, and we think it's right that shareholders decide. We will keep the cost of the meeting as low as we reasonably can. Second, timing. As shareholders know, the Company had to complete its FY26 audit and lodge its accounts before it could hold this meeting, and the AGM was already later than we would have wanted. The notice of meeting had to go out well before today, and at that point the terms of the capital raising had not been finalised. The structure changed during October in response to investor interest, and the Board could not put a resolution to shareholders on a transaction that had not been agreed or announced.
Q4. Our share registry provider MUFG has a perfectly good online meetings platform. Why didn't we use that today rather than juggling two systems with MUFG for voting and Zoom for questions and viewing? Will you use MUFG exclusively for the upcoming December 14 EGM and will that also be a virtual meeting? Would you agree that hybrid meetings are best practice? Why not do hybrids going forward?
CFO Amanda Cribb provided the following written response via Zoom: Thank you, Mr Mayne. The short answer is cost. MUFG's integrated platform is more expensive than the arrangement we used today, and given the Company's current position, the Board has been careful with every dollar of discretionary spending. Today's format let shareholders view the meeting, ask questions and vote, at a lower cost. We take your point about convenience. The Board will consider the format for the EGM, including whether to use MUFG's platform alone, and will confirm the arrangements in the notice of meeting. On hybrid meetings, we acknowledge that many shareholders and governance commentators regard them as best practice. For a company of our size, the cost of a physical venue alongside an online platform is significant, but we will keep the format under review as the Company's position improves.
Q5. Why the 25% proxy vote against Ron? Could he give a brief stump speech to shareholders today? Is he online at today's meeting?"
Answer: Yes he was, online from the US. With $70m smoked at Straker/Arbitr and the company on its knees after the devastating $US5.2m employee theft in the US, new American director Ron Heinz is the hope of the side, with his funds putting an extra $1m in as part of today's $5m capital raise. Here's his impressive stump speech via Twitter.
I then lodged a series of questions as the proxy votes were disclosed showing big protests votes and some defeats. They included the following questions, all of which were ignored:
"This has been defeated on the proxies. Please don't ask for approval again."
"It looks like Linda's options have been defeated. Who is voting against so many options today? Is it Bailador or Straker?"
"Please address my questions about all these large proxy protest votes. Who is voting against?"
See the video evidence via Twitter of all these questions being ignored, including when chair Linda Jenkinson introduced the motion for her own options grants, which was also defeated.
Copyright © 2026 The Mayne Report. All rights reserved