Q1. Is this David Williams' first election at an ASX-listed company since he was voted off the Polynovo board last year? What lessons did he learn from that bruising experience and has there been a material proxy protest vote against his re-election today?
Answer: David Williams stressed that he resigned and wasn't voted off. Yes David, the under your exit deal the Polynovo proxy votes were never publicly disclosed but you quit on the morning of the Polynovo AGM when you knew your goose was cooked. There were no reflections offered or lessons learnt and he ploughs on with a range of small public company board gigs. A leopard doesn't change its spots because on introducing new Arovella CEO Dr Nicole Van Der Weerden to present, he literally said: "You're a horror to work with but I was able to match you, so that's good". Watch video of Polynovo exchange via Twitter.
Q2. A 13.5% proxy turn out on the shares metric is very low. Does that suggest we have few institutional shareholders and a very retail heavy investment base. How many shareholders voted on this rem report item and was there a material protest vote?
Answer: The enthusiastic Automic question wrangler jumped in a tad early, reading out this rem report question when chair David Williams was dealing with the accounts. “You can sit down” he told her before not comprehending the question. Watch video of exchange via Twitter, plus these additional comments by chair Williams as he struggled to understand that his script said 13.5% of Arovella's issued capital had voted by proxy, so that means 86.5% of votes stayed home, David. He was focused on the percentages of directed proxies for and against.
Q3. There have been many substantial protest votes against resolutions like this at public companies over the years and multiple defeats. It is not good practice to allow a board to selectively place up to 25% of the company's shares to anyone they like over a 12 month period, diluting the existing shareholders without compensation for their lost property rights. Why are we asking for this authority and has there been a substantial protest vote against this resolution? Placements favour big end of town investors at the expense of retail and even when retail are offered an SPP, the mast majority don't participate.
Answer: Got the usual flexibility blather from David Williams. Watch video of exchange via Twitter. Also, it was good to see Arovella retail shareholders earlier knocked over the refresh of the 2m options grant to broker Blue Ocean Equities even if chair David Williams was playing it down. It didn't make sense to back the extra placement capacity if you were opposing a refresh on the broker options.
Copyright © 2026 The Mayne Report. All rights reserved